Optimists see change as opportunity. Pessimists find change to be irritating, risky at best. Realists weigh change one case at a time.
Doctors face a paradigm shift in how they interact with government. Binding interest arbitration (BA) promises to fix a power imbalance between doctors and government. Many docs have wanted BA for years.
But will BA fix everything between doctors and government?
Are there reasons to vote against BA?
Reasons to Vote No
A few doctors believe that there are 4 insuperable reasons to vote against this contract. If you agree with these four, then you should vote No, too. Continue reading “Looking for Reasons to Oppose Binding Arbitration”
After years of wrestling a more powerful opponent, doctors opened their emails to find that government had offered a truce.
I never expected to see this.
Who would give up such advantage?
Government used to rule supreme. It could legislate whatever it wanted.
Why would government change its mind and give up absolute power?
A part of me must have believed that this would happen. Why else would I have spent years lamenting government power and control?
In hindsight, things had to change.
Government was trying to lead a horse to water that would not drink. Continue reading “Binding Interest Arbitration – A New Era?”
Like the last post, many people have asked for copies of my first address to Council as President.
A number have shared bits and pieces on social media, so I thought it was best just to share the whole thing here.
This is just a starting point. I look forward to seeing where we – all of us – take this from here.
Thank you, Mr. Chair, Members of Council and Special Guests.
In my election speech, I offered three priorities for the OMA over the next year: trust, unity and excellence. I’d like to expand those ideas a bit more over the next few minutes. I offer these for discussion. I hope you will argue with me. I offer them as a starting point to a larger conversation.
Everyone agrees: We need an agreement. But we need more than that. We might get a wonderful agreement. But if we do not have a system—the excellence—to socialize it with our members, it will fail. Continue reading “First Address to Council”
A number of doctors have requested my election speech, and others have posted parts of it on social media already. So, I though it best to put down what I said.
Doctors have a new hope for positive change. They are eager to build. It feels like we have turned a corner.
Thanks so much to everyone who worked so hard this weekend!
Thank you Mr. Chair and Members of Council.
It’s time for change.
The OMA faced an unprecedented crisis:
We’ve been heckled in the legislature,
slandered in the media,
ignored for multiple pieces of legislation,
and now, after almost 4 years, we still don’t have a contract.
This is intolerable.
The OMA must do 3 things to fix this. Continue reading “Whatley Election Speech”
Most doctors want to see patients, not fight government. Doctors pay dues so that their medical associations will speak for them.
Is it even possible for a medical association to tell the truth about problems inside healthcare?
Can doctors speak about problems, without fear that the government will punish doctors for doing so?
Public Relations in Medicare
Everyone in our single payer system wrestles with what to say. Hospitals, associations, unions and patient groups must choose carefully what to say about:
- Patients suffering on wait lists.
- Provincial budgets that fall short.
- System mismanagement.
One option is to only share good news, all the time. If you have something bad to say, do not say it publicly.
This is the most popular approach. Nothing panics hospital administrators more than hearing that one of their nurses or doctors has sent bad news to the media. Continue reading “Public Relations Strategy or Just Tell the Truth?”
We hire a real estate agent to help us find a house. She only gets paid when a deal closes.
Good agents try to find something we will like.
But that takes time.
Agents have to ask questions, listen to us and then test what they have heard by showing us a few houses.
Often, agents hear wrong, or we do not explain ourselves very well.
Good real estate agents spend time and money to learn how to represent our interests with confidence.
Bad agents try to close a deal as soon as possible.
The OMA is negotiating a dispute resolution process with government, right now.
Doctors want this.
We hope the dispute resolution process will be fair and reasonable. The OMA tells doctors that it is moving along well.
But as soon as the OMA and government agree to a dispute resolution process, the government will want to begin negotiations on a physician services agreement (aka contract).
Who could blame it?
An election looms.
The government finally wants to resolve labour problems with doctors. It does not want to drag negotiations into the fall, or next year.
The OMA will face immense pressure to enter negotiations as soon as they have settled a dispute resolution process. Continue reading “Doctors Need a Good Agent – OMA Negotiations”
There are two kinds of homeowners. The first kind would never change faucets and doorknobs. They buy a house, tear it down and start over.
Other people keep what they can tolerate. They cannot afford to be radical.
No matter the approach, everyone agrees: The point of renovation is to rebuild.
Like an old house, the OMA sprawls with additions, legacy rooms and dark closets unfit for visitors. It’s tired and dysfunctional. Most people finally admit it.
The OMA was never built to service 42,000 members. It was not designed to command a battle with an activist, majority government in the trenches of social media.
Crisis can bring out the best in people. It often brings out the worst in organizations. The OMA crisis exposed problems that no one talked about when times were good. Continue reading “Time to Rebuild the OMA”
The movie, It’s a Wonderful Life, is a political thriller, despite all the crying, hugging and cuteness.
At its core, the movie portrays a battle of political visions.
Will George Bailey accept Mr. Potter’s salary in exchange for Mr. Potter’s iron control of Bailey’s Savings and Loan?
Will George stand up for his own political vision, of small loans for his neighbours, or will he sacrifice his integrity for Mr. Potter’s vision of control and serfdom under Potter?
The movie pivots on George’s refusal to accept Potter’s vision of reality.
The following 2 minute, 30 second clip captures the struggle:
Once surrendered, integrity is almost impossible to regain. Some say doctors have surrendered too much already. We gave in years ago: Better to compromise and get a raise than lose a fight and suffer more fee cuts! Continue reading “Political Vision Must Come Before Negotiation”
Fundamentalism simplifies life. It turns a messy world, full of grey, into a crisp, clean existence of peace and clarity. Even dogs and colour-blind people can see black and white.
Fundamentalism uses publicists to guide true believers.
Some news columnists, ersatz journalists, make their living as publicists. They sell words that paint the same, stark plot: Everyone is good or bad, oppressed or oppressor.
Stylites in the Main Stream Media chant their sermons, while the choir nods in unison.
Doctors are oppressors, arrogant and powerful.
Liberal members of parliament are warriors for social justice.
Not even Odysseus could sail between the publicists and warriors unscathed. Black and white makes life so simple.
Most people expect news-papers to report the news, not create it.
Now, many newspapers only write about events that support their narrative. Continue reading “Fundamentalism in Medical Politics”
Some people hate cows.
Cow haters often have good reasons for feeling so.
Perhaps they had a bad experience with a scary cow. Now they tell everyone that cows are smelly and bad for your health.
Occasionally, cow haters pretend to support the dairy industry, but only if it leads to increased regulation of cows in general:
Cows are such a precious resource that we need government to control them.
Other people love cows above all else and put them centre stage at every state fair. They push for more pasture, just for cattle. They re-write food guides to support the dairy industry.
Some people hate doctors.
No doubt, doctor-haters have deep reasons for feeling so. Perhaps they had a bad experience with a scary doctor.
Now, they write nasty columns in the Toronto Star about doctors. All the inspiration they need is a tweet, by a famously unpopular Premier from the 1990s. Continue reading “Doctor Derangement Syndrome”