Is Self-Regulation Dead?

I believe the term ‘self-regulation’ is well on its way to the dustbin of history.”

With this, the registrar of the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario (CPSO) wrapped up his final note in From the Registrar’s Desk.

He went on,

In the future, College work will no longer be described as ‘the privilege of self-regulation,’ but instead ‘the responsibility of medical regulation.’

Candor comes easy when people leave office.

Is Self-Regulation Dead?

 

Was the registrar simply making an observation, or was he stating what he believes to be good? Does he believe self-regulation belongs in the dustbin?

I know many doctors who became Chiefs of departments. Chiefs oversee quality. They handle patient complaints.

Chiefs see problems before they become patterns. A good Chief tries to build safety into a department to prevent problems becoming patterns.

Good Chiefs try education, encouragement and incentives as ways to improve quality.

But they never eliminate problems, and many Chiefs start to despair.

So, they take charge.

They make tough decisions.

They put their faith in power: rules, oversight, punishment.

After 10 years in charge, some Chiefs are damaged; irreversibly anti-physician. They lose hope in clinical judgement and put their faith in systems instead of people. Continue reading “Is Self-Regulation Dead?”

Offence, Free Speech and a Code of Conduct

I’m offended.

You’re offensive.

I’m offended that you are offended!

Two train wrecks have collided around free speech in medical politics right now.

The first has to do with the politically correct/social justice warrior/virtue signalling/identity politics movement.

Proclaiming personal offence has replaced sticking out one’s tongue in the schoolyard of adult conversation. Signalling solidarity with every oppressed group is the new morality.

Thou shalt show empathy.

Thou shalt not ask rational questions such as, “Why can’t you afford meds, but you upgrade your iPhone every 6 months?

Brace yourself. People will take offence. Listeners will join a mob to signal their own virtue at your malfeasance.

There is only one accepted view. Questions are out. Debate is unwelcome.

The second train wreck has to do with the Summer of 2016. It was a dark and nasty time for doctors in Ontario. Continue reading “Offence, Free Speech and a Code of Conduct”

Moral Hazard and OHIP+

We scrambled to book massages and orthotics for our children.

The year was almost over. We had unused health benefits.

Did they need a massage?

Who determines need versus want?

Do need and want overlap? If not, where does one end and the other start?

Economists teach us that demand for free products and services is infinite.

Voters experience the limits of free government products and services as rationing. Stuff runs out. Wait lines form. Continue reading “Moral Hazard and OHIP+”